Welcome to our forensic evidence wiki
This wiki catalogues empirical evidence relating to forensic evidence and miscarriages of justice.
Forensic Evidence Related Miscarriages of Justice in the UK
Total cases:
81
Years lost:
556.14
Average years lost:
6.87
1
John Preece
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
8
Year of crime:
1972
Year of initial conviction:
1972
Year conviction overturned:
1981
View case
1972
2
Andrew Evans
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
25
Year of crime:
1972
Year of initial conviction:
1973
Year conviction overturned:
1997
View case
Stephen Downing
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
27
Year of crime:
1973
Year of initial conviction:
1973
Year conviction overturned:
2001
View case
1973
1
Judith Ward
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
18
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1974
Year conviction overturned:
1992
View case
1974
7
Paddy Hill
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
16
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1975
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Gerry Hunter
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
16
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1975
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Johnny Walker
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
16
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1975
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Hugh Callaghan
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
16
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1975
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Billy Power
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
16
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1975
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Richard McIIkenny
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
16
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1975
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Patrick Nicholls
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
23
Year of crime:
1975
Year of initial conviction:
1975
Year conviction overturned:
1998
View case
1975
8
Noel Jones
Most serious offence:
Manslaughter / non-fatal offence against the person
Years in prison:
6
Year of crime:
1976
Year of initial conviction:
1976
Year conviction overturned:
2019
View case
Anne Maguire
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
14
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1976
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Patrick Snr Maguire
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
14
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1976
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Patrick Jnr Maguire
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
4
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1976
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Vincent Maguire
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
5
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1976
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Sean Smyth
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
12
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1976
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Patrick O’Neil
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
8
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1976
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
Patrick Conlon
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
4
Year of crime:
1974
Year of initial conviction:
1976
Year conviction overturned:
1991
View case
1976
1
Andrew Smith
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
22
Year of crime:
1976
Year of initial conviction:
1977
Year conviction overturned:
2000
View case
1977
1978
1979
1980
1
Colin Wallace
Most serious offence:
Manslaughter / non-fatal offence against the person
Years in prison:
6
Year of crime:
1980
Year of initial conviction:
1981
Year conviction overturned:
1996
View case
1981
1
Raymond Gilmour
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
21
Year of crime:
1981
Year of initial conviction:
1982
Year conviction overturned:
2007
View case
1982
1983
1984
2
George McPhee
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
18
Year of crime:
1985
Year of initial conviction:
1985
Year conviction overturned:
2005
View case
Hassan Assali
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
7
Year of crime:
1983
Year of initial conviction:
1985
Year conviction overturned:
2005
View case
1985
1986
1
Gilbert (Danny) McNamee
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
11
Year of crime:
1982
Year of initial conviction:
1987
Year conviction overturned:
1998
View case
1987
2
Michael Shirley
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
16
Year of crime:
1986
Year of initial conviction:
1988
Year conviction overturned:
2003
View case
Jacqueline Fletcher
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
4
Year of crime:
1984
Year of initial conviction:
1988
Year conviction overturned:
1992
View case
1988
1
Brian Kelly
Most serious offence:
Sexual offences
Years in prison:
4
Year of crime:
1987
Year of initial conviction:
1989
Year conviction overturned:
2004
View case
1989
1
Reginald F
Most serious offence:
Sexual offences
Years in prison:
9
Year of crime:
Unknown
Year of initial conviction:
1990
Year conviction overturned:
2002
View case
1990
2
Kevin Callan
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
4
Year of crime:
1990
Year of initial conviction:
1991
Year conviction overturned:
1995
View case
Christy Walsh
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
14
Year of crime:
1991
Year of initial conviction:
1991
Year conviction overturned:
2010
View case
1991
2
Lisa Taylor
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
1
Year of crime:
1991
Year of initial conviction:
1992
Year conviction overturned:
1993
View case
Michelle Taylor
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
1
Year of crime:
1991
Year of initial conviction:
1992
Year conviction overturned:
1993
View case
1992
1993
1994
1
Richard Karling
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
5
Year of crime:
1995
Year of initial conviction:
1995
Year conviction overturned:
2001
View case
1995
2
Amanda Jenkinson
Most serious offence:
Manslaughter / non-fatal offence against the person
Years in prison:
4.92
Year of crime:
1993
Year of initial conviction:
1996
Year conviction overturned:
2005
View case
Kevin John Brown
Most serious offence:
Sexual offences
Years in prison:
7
Year of crime:
1995
Year of initial conviction:
1996
Year conviction overturned:
2003
View case
1996
4
Anthony O’Doherty
Most serious offence:
Manslaughter / non-fatal offence against the person
Years in prison:
4
Year of crime:
1995
Year of initial conviction:
1997
Year conviction overturned:
2002
View case
David Asbury
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
3.5
Year of crime:
1997
Year of initial conviction:
1997
Year conviction overturned:
2002
View case
Joseph Otoo
Most serious offence:
Robbery / burglary
Years in prison:
3
Year of crime:
1995
Year of initial conviction:
1997
Year conviction overturned:
2000
View case
Colin John C
Most serious offence:
Sexual offences
Years in prison:
Unknown
Year of crime:
1996-1997
Year of initial conviction:
1997
Year conviction overturned:
2010
View case
1997
7
Serena Kayretli
Most serious offence:
Manslaughter / non-fatal offence against the person
Years in prison:
2
Year of crime:
1996
Year of initial conviction:
1998
Year conviction overturned:
2000
View case
Veydat Kayretli
Most serious offence:
Manslaughter / non-fatal offence against the person
Years in prison:
2
Year of crime:
1996
Year of initial conviction:
1998
Year conviction overturned:
2000
View case
Mark Dallagher
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
6
Year of crime:
1996
Year of initial conviction:
1998
Year conviction overturned:
2002
View case
Donna Anthony
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
6
Year of crime:
1996, 1997
Year of initial conviction:
1998
Year conviction overturned:
2005
View case
Michael Byrne
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
8
Year of crime:
1996
Year of initial conviction:
1998
Year conviction overturned:
2006
View case
Sion Jenkins
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
6
Year of crime:
1997
Year of initial conviction:
1998
Year conviction overturned:
2004
View case
Justin Plummer
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
3
Year of crime:
1997
Year of initial conviction:
1998
Year conviction overturned:
2021
View case
1998
3
Ian Faulder
Most serious offence:
Manslaughter / non-fatal offence against the person
Years in prison:
2.5
Year of crime:
1998
Year of initial conviction:
1999
Year conviction overturned:
2005
View case
Sally Clark
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
3
Year of crime:
1996, 1998
Year of initial conviction:
1999
Year conviction overturned:
2003
View case
Stephen Aston
Most serious offence:
Sexual offences
Year of crime:
1993/1994
Year of initial conviction:
1999
Year conviction overturned:
2010
View case
1999
3
Lorraine Allen
Most serious offence:
Manslaughter / non-fatal offence against the person
Years in prison:
1.3
Year of crime:
1998
Year of initial conviction:
2000
Year conviction overturned:
2005
View case
Julie Ferris
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
2
Year of crime:
Unknown
Year of initial conviction:
2000
Year conviction overturned:
2003
View case
Aaron Bacchus
Most serious offence:
Robbery / burglary
Years in prison:
4
Year of crime:
1999
Year of initial conviction:
2000
Year conviction overturned:
2004
View case
2000
3
Barry George
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
7
Year of crime:
1999
Year of initial conviction:
2001
Year conviction overturned:
2008
View case
Mark Kempster
Most serious offence:
Robbery / burglary
Year of crime:
2000
Year of initial conviction:
2001
Year conviction overturned:
2008
View case
Kenneth Samuels
Most serious offence:
Sexual offences
Years in prison:
6
Year of crime:
Unknown
Year of initial conviction:
2001
Year conviction overturned:
2007
View case
2001
8
Angela Cannings
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
1.5
Year of crime:
1991, 1999
Year of initial conviction:
2002
Year conviction overturned:
2003
View case
Margaret Smith
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
1
Year of crime:
1994
Year of initial conviction:
2002
Year conviction overturned:
2004
View case
Dwaine Simeon George
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
12
Year of crime:
2001
Year of initial conviction:
2002
Year conviction overturned:
2014
View case
Barri White
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
6
Year of crime:
2000
Year of initial conviction:
2002
Year conviction overturned:
2008
View case
Steven Puaca
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
3
Year of crime:
2002
Year of initial conviction:
2002
Year conviction overturned:
2005
View case
Keith Hyatt
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
2.5
Year of crime:
2000
Year of initial conviction:
2002
Year conviction overturned:
2007
View case
Christopher Scott P
Most serious offence:
Sexual offences
Years in prison:
2
Year of crime:
2001
Year of initial conviction:
2002
Year conviction overturned:
2004
View case
P P
Most serious offence:
Sexual offences
Years in prison:
3
Year of initial conviction:
2002
Year conviction overturned:
2005
View case
2002
1
Barry Campbell
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
5
Year of crime:
2002
Year of initial conviction:
2003
Year conviction overturned:
2008
View case
2003
2004
3
Angela Gay
Most serious offence:
Manslaughter / non-fatal offence against the person
Years in prison:
1.25
Year of crime:
2002
Year of initial conviction:
2005
Year conviction overturned:
2007
View case
Ian Gay
Most serious offence:
Manslaughter / non-fatal offence against the person
Years in prison:
1.25
Year of crime:
2002
Year of initial conviction:
2005
Year conviction overturned:
2007
View case
Suzanne Holdsworth
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
3
Year of crime:
2004
Year of initial conviction:
2005
Year conviction overturned:
2008
View case
2005
1
Sirfraze Ahmed
Most serious offence:
Robbery / burglary
Years in prison:
0.67
Year of crime:
2004
Year of initial conviction:
2006
Year conviction overturned:
2007
View case
2006
1
Amilton-Nicolas Bento
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
2
Year of crime:
2005
Year of initial conviction:
2007
Year conviction overturned:
2009
View case
2007
2
Thomas Smart
Most serious offence:
Other
Year of crime:
2008
Year of initial conviction:
2008
Year conviction overturned:
2009
View case
Gareth Jones
Most serious offence:
Sexual offences
Years in prison:
3.5
Year of crime:
2007
Year of initial conviction:
2008
Year conviction overturned:
2018
View case
2008
1
Claire Thompson
Most serious offence:
Manslaughter / non-fatal offence against the person
Year of crime:
Unknown
Year of initial conviction:
2009
Year conviction overturned:
2011
View case
2009
2010
2
Kimberley Hainey
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
2
Year of crime:
2010
Year of initial conviction:
2011
Year conviction overturned:
2013
View case
Gillian Clemo
Most serious offence:
Other
Year of initial conviction:
2011
Year conviction overturned:
2014
View case
2011
1
Brian Shivers
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
1
Year of crime:
2009
Year of initial conviction:
2012
Year conviction overturned:
2013
View case
2012
1
Danny Steven Kay
Most serious offence:
Sexual offences
Years in prison:
4
Year of crime:
Unknown
Year of initial conviction:
2013
Year conviction overturned:
2017
View case
2013
1
David Dunbar
Most serious offence:
Drugs offences
Years in prison:
0.75
Year of crime:
2014
Year of initial conviction:
2014
Year conviction overturned:
2015
View case
2014
1
Jodie Rana
Most serious offence:
Other
Years in prison:
2.5
Year of crime:
2014
Year of initial conviction:
2015
Year conviction overturned:
2018
View case
2015
2
Patryk Pachecka
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
5
Year of crime:
2016
Year of initial conviction:
2016
Year conviction overturned:
2021
View case
Grzegorz Szal
Most serious offence:
Murder
Years in prison:
5
Year of crime:
2016
Year of initial conviction:
2016
Year conviction overturned:
2021
View case
2016
Illustrative cases from the UK
Paddy Hill
View Case
Angela Cannings
View Case
Sally Clark
View Case
Stephen Downing
View Case
Barry George
View Case
Patrick Jnr Maguire
View Case
Colin Wallace
View Case
Donna Anthony
View Case
Judith Ward
View Case
Kevin Callan
View Case
Lisa Taylor
View Case
Michael Shirley
View Case
Sion Jenkins
View Case
Ian Gay
View Case