Judith Elizabeth Smith
Year of crime:
2007
Year conviction was overturned:
2024
Judith Smith was a sub-postmaster who pled guilty to false accounting (uttering false accounts) in excess of £3,000. She said that she had inflated cash on hand figures to make accounts balance after the Horizon helpdesk was unable to provide assistance in relation to apparent shortfalls.
Her conviction was overturned when it became clear that evidence undermining Horizon had been suppressed and that bugs, errors, and defects in Horizon could, and did, cause discrepancies and shortfalls in branch accounts.
< Back to Case Search < Back to Overview Graph- Offence: False accounting
- Jurisdiction: Scotland
- Gender: F
- Offence convicted of: False Accounting
- Year of crime: 2007
- Year of initial conviction: 2009
- Year conviction was overturned: 2024
- CCRC Referral: Yes
- Post Office Case: Y
- Link to full case: https://www.sccrc.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/30-April-2024-Issued-Decision-Susan-Sinclair-v-HMA.pdf
- Compensation: Yes
- Crown argued case at CofA: No
- Retrial: No